Blog Post #86 – 4 steps for Conducting an ‘Internal Accident Investigation’

Blog Post #86 – 4 steps for Conducting an ‘Internal Accident Investigation’

Written by Timothy Bryant 21 September 2010

It is any workplace’s worst nightmare: an injury to a worker while on the job. Yet for all the horror it brings, it is also a disturbingly common event. Employers are required by law to take all steps necessary to prevent their workers from being injured on the job. But what happens if a worker does get hurt?

Because workplace injury is a reality that many employers may face, will face or have faced at some point, it’s wise to have a plan for when an accident does happen, according to OHS legal experts.

The first thing every employer needs to have is an accident plan, says Jeremy Warning, a senior associate with Toronto-based law firm Heenan Blaikie.

The purpose of coming up with an accident plan ahead of time – even before a workplace injury takes place – is to ensure that when an accident occurs, “everyone knows what steps are to be carried out and who is going to be notified and responsible for ensuring those steps,” he says.

Warning says the exact steps to follow in the event of an accident depend on the accident itself.

“There’s going to be no script to follow on conducting an internal investigation, and that the steps that are required will vary from circumstance to circumstance,” he says.

Although the exact steps will vary, Warning does say the general procedure is fairly consistent across many situations.

Accident aftermath
The first step is to provide medical aid to any injured parties. This also includes speaking to them, when possible, about what happened, says Ryan Conlin, a partner with Stringer Brisbin Humphrey.

The second step is to determine if the site needs to be held (locked down), or if the regulator (e.g. the Ministry of Labour) needs to be notified. There are several legal requirements for when a site needs to be held, Warning says, such as when there has been a fatality.

Another requirement for the site being held is if a worker suffers a critical injury. The Occupational Health and Safety Act in Ontario, defines a critical injury as “an injury of a serious nature that, (a) places life in jeopardy; (b) produces unconsciousness; (c) results in substantial loss of blood; (d) involves the fracture of a leg or arm but not a finger or toe; (e) involves the amputation of a leg, arm, hand or foot but not a finger or toe; (f) consists of burns to a major portion of the body; or (g) causes the loss of sight in an eye.”

The final step is to appoint an accident response coordinator. This person will generally take over the company’s internal accident investigation, and is designated through the company’s accident response plan.

At this point, the company is best served by performing its own internal accident investigation. Conlin says the investigation serves primarily as a fact-finding exercise.

“An internal accident investigation is one where an employer is gathering information for the purposes of any potential litigation arising out of the accident,” he says. “At the end of the day, it is a way for the organization to gather all of the information for the purposes of getting legal advice if that becomes necessary.”

Before beginning an investigation, the company must decide if it needs to retain legal counsel to help it through the process. For Warning, it makes sense to retain counsel at this point, as the benefits are many.

“Engaging counsel as early on in the process is highly recommended because counsel specialized in health and safety matters can provide guidance on a number of issues,” he says. “Not only in identifying potential gaps in an investigation, but also for identifying what legal risks are there too, which will direct the investigation.”

Once an investigation starts, employers follow the same steps no matter the situation.

Step One: The accident scene
The first step in an internal investigation is to examine the scene of the incident and any involved equipment, Warning says. This includes reviewing maintenance records, manufacturer’s or operator’s manuals, pre-start health and safety reviews and any prior regulator visit reports.

Once this initial examination has been completed, the company will be able to determine if it needs to bring in a professional to assist with the investigation. This could be necessary if the cause of the incident does not seem readily apparent and the inclusion of an engineer or forensic investigator, with their technical knowledge, would be able to provide insight, says Warning.

Step Two: The visuals
The next important step in an investigation is to take photographs of the scene. In addition to the photographs, it is useful to take as many measurements as possible. These measurements can be used to create diagrams of the scene, which should also include all the people in the area and what they were doing, says Conlin.

Step Three: The witnesses
Following this, it is necessary to speak to any and all witnesses to the incident. This not only means speaking to those who were present at the time of the incident, but also those who may have information that can round out what may have happened. These potential witnesses include those with the same job or role as the injured party, any supervisors or trainers, or those who have relevant health and safety-related knowledge, Warning says. As an added step, Conlin suggests getting each witness to sign his or her statement.

Step Four: The review
Warning suggests reviewing a collection of documents in order to round out the investigation. He says it is to a company’s advantage to review the training records of the injured party, as well as those of other workers who perform the same job and other workers who were involved in the incident.

The review should also extend to identifying and correcting any relevant workplace policies and procedures, including proof of any third-party training or licensing. Finally, the investigation should review internal health and safety steps, including joint health and safety committee minutes to see if anything relevant to the incident had been discussed in the past.

Choosing the investigator
When performing an internal accident investigation, there is often a question as to who will perform the investigation: an in-house employee, a law firm or a safety consultant?

The answer would depend on the company and the severity of the incident, says Conlin. For an organization of significant size, it is likely there would be a safety professional on staff to perform the investigation. For smaller companies, the likely candidate would be an HR person at a fairly senior level.

In the case of a serious incident, Conlin says it would be more likely for the organization to bring in outside assistance in the form of a safety consultant or law firm. This can often lead to the investigation wrapping up quicker.

“Most accident investigations from an external resource can be completed in less than a day,” he says.

It’s up to the company seeking to do the investigation to decide who would do the job best, says Warning.

“In terms of who is used, it’s really a comfort-level decision for the organization in that whoever is conducting the investigation will be someone who is intimately familiar with the legislative requirements and also the legal framework within which they’re operating,” he says.

Once the investigation is complete, a report is often drawn up that will outline the investigation’s findings. This report will contain valuable information for the company, as well as valuable information for any government inspector investigating the incident. As such, both Warning and Conlin stress the importance of making the report privileged.

Confidentiality
In this situation, there are two types of privilege that can be applied: contemplated litigation privilege and solicitor-client privilege. Contemplated litigation privilege does not need a lawyer to be invoked, while solicitor-client privilege does.

Both privileges enable the company to keep the information in the report confidential, but for different reasons. As evidenced by the name, contemplated litigation privilege can be invoked when the information is being compiled in anticipation of legal proceedings.

On the other hand, solicitor-client privilege is invoked in two ways. The first is when legal counsel requests a report be prepared. The second is when an already-prepared report is sent to legal counsel for review.

The benefit to making the report privileged is that, in the event the company faces charges as a result of the workplace incident, the prosecution cannot use the report to strengthen its case. The report may include information that can lead to more charges against the company, as well as provide the prosecution with leads it may not have followed.

“It can be of great assistance to a prosecutor who has never been to the site, likely never will be to the scene of the accident and is relying entirely on the report or the information gathered by the [government] inspector or officer,” Warning says.

With this in mind, it is integral the privilege be maintained, which is done by limiting who has access to the report. In most cases, the only people who should have access to it are legal counsel, senior management and the persons who prepared the report. Furthermore, there should only be as many copies as necessary, and all kept in a secure place.

However, both Warning and Conlin say it is important to realize that privilege is not absolute, and that it can be waived both explicitly and by conduct. Since privilege can be considered to be waived simply by disseminating the report to those who are not covered by the privilege, it is critical the report not be made widely available.

Dan
Share

102 Comments

  1. McGurren

    I am so glad that I came across this article.

  2. Aiava

    Excellent information.

  3. Robin Smith

    Well, this is a very informative post to all of us. Today workplace accident is a very common fact. But we should not neglect this.

  4. Kahalehoe

    Thanks sure is alot of info you have on your website!

  5. Stanley Baczeski

    Jesus, somebody call ma, really love this blog.

  6. Desi Nuggs

    Great, great blog! I hope you continue well and you have a great day. Cheers!

  7. Barb Oconnor

    I want to thank you for all the great information you are providing.

  8. Ashlee Anthony

    Hi! I just adore your post! I couldn’t find a contact form so I hope you take offense to me reaching you here. Wow, I came by a great idea for your interesting blog.

  9. Trudi Klukan

    Hey! I loved your post; it’s better than 90% of the other blog posts I read (and I mean it)!

  10. Becky Manges

    Hi! My family really adore your website! I couldn’t find an email form so I hope you take offense to me reaching you here.

  11. Paul King

    Excellent work you have done here.

  12. Lydia Veldiza

    You are an excellent blogger.

  13. Heather

    Keep it up. Nicely done.

  14. Angie Kauffman

    Hey! I saw your website and I thought I should pass along something you’ll definitely be interested in. Keep up the good work.

  15. Courtney Ceacal

    I just want to say thank you, even if you don’t know me you’ve made a difference in my life. I hope you find whatever you’re looking for today. Cheers! Courtney Ceacal

  16. Steve Johnson

    Well, this is a very informative post to all of us. Today workplace accident is a very common fact. But we should not neglect this. Accident Reconstruction Expert can help you to safeguard our life.

  17. Sandy Leffler

    Hey, I’m impressed with your website management and writing skills, makes me wish I had started younger.

  18. Amy Duby

    Jesus, somebody call ma, really love this blog .

  19. Everhart

    Great review! You actually covered some nice news here. I came across it by using Google and I’ve got to admit that I already subscribed to the site, will be following you on my iphone :)

  20. Ursino

    Excellent information.

  21. Lucas Slovick

    Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely comeback.

  22. Fortier

    This is one great website!

  23. Bigney

    Bookmarking now thanks, are you on twitter?

  24. Laborin

    Thanks so much for this wonderful article. Being a avid blogger, I’m happy to see others taking initiative and contributing to the community. I just wanted to comment to show my appreciation for your post as it’s very encouraging, and many writers do not get the credit they deserve.

  25. Wariner

    I want to thank you for all the great information you are providing.

  26. Catinella

    I find it difficult to subscribe RSS feeds, bookmark this site anyway I have is a very useful and complete information.

  27. Drumwright

    I find it difficult to subscribe RSS feeds, bookmark this site anyway I have is a very useful and complete information.

  28. Enslow

    Hey very nice blog!! Man…Beautiful.. Amazing..I will bookmark you blog and take the feed also…

  29. Domini Durge

    Thanks so much for this great article;this is the words that keeps me going through the day. I am sure I’ll visit again and will send some of my friends.

  30. Buddy

    Actually niсe pаttern and fantastic content , аbsolutely nothing elsе we neeԁ : D.

  31. Norton

    This is good stuff!

  32. Trudy

    I’m really enjoying the design and layout of your site.

  33. Adrienne

    I read a lot of interesting articles here. Probably you spend a
    lot of time writing.

  34. Chandler

    Thank you!

  35. Cathy Awalt

    Gorgeous material!

  36. Donna

    Many thanks!

  37. Carol Greenfield

    Good information needed to know!

  38. Sean

    I wanted this all along!

  39. Corrine

    World class!

  40. Ann Pinczak

    I will return!

  41. Shelby

    Nicely written!

  42. Carol Greenfield

    Wonderfully written!

  43. Corrine

    Many thanks!

  44. Sean

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing!

  45. Kenneth

    I will follow you!

  46. Amber

    Many thanks!

  47. Harrison

    Wonderful!!!

  48. Sharon Woods

    Many thanks!

  49. Freddie

    Many thanks!

  50. Abe Fullwood

    Many thanks!

  51. Phil Hastings

    I wonder what comes next?

  52. Tiffany

    Good for you!

  53. Amber

    I really liked this site!

  54. Kenneth

    I love coming here!

  55. Ann Pinczak

    This is really good!

  56. Donna

    Great article!

  57. Corrine

    I will be back again!

  58. Donna

    Good article!

  59. Quincy

    This is really good!

  60. Sharon Woods

    Good article!

  61. Corrine

    Good for you!

  62. Amber

    I will return!

  63. Tiffany

    People like reading your material!

  64. Ewing

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing!

  65. Ashley

    One of your best!

  66. Dennis

    Nicely written!

  67. Yvette

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing!

  68. Wanda

    I love this site!

  69. Kyle Laughlin

    I needed this!

  70. Katherine

    I love this site!

  71. Tiffany

    Excellent!

  72. Cathy Awalt

    Thank you for the post!

  73. Leslie

    More of the same!

  74. Donna

    I needed this!

  75. Amber

    You are the best!

  76. Ophelia

    I needed this!

  77. Kenneth

    Thank you!

  78. Donna

    I will follow you!

  79. Zachary

    Nice to see someone putting this stuff out there. Thanks!

  80. Kenneth

    Excellent!

  81. Aaron

    Good to know!

  82. Velda and Morris

    Keep up writing.

  83. Darcie

    If you are going for best contents like I do, only go to see this web site all the time for the reason that it gives quality
    contents, thanks!

  84. Amee

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on WSIB. Regards

  85. Gerard

    I like looking through a post that can make people think.

  86. Debora Ribsamen

    Excellent post! We will be linking to this particularly great content on our site.

    Keep up the good writing.

  87. Carrol Fjeseth

    I hope to give something back and help to others like you helped me.

  88. Mariah Shreck

    Wonderful posting!

  89. Arron Milius

    Thanks for your marvelous posting!

  90. Shirley Dura

    I could not resist commenting. Exceptionally well written!

  91. Alden and Paula

    This web site consists of valuable Information.

  92. Kenneth

    Good stories!

  93. Kathy

    I’m not sure why but this website is loading very slow for me.

  94. Alice

    I certainly like your web site.

  95. Roger

    Excellent submit, very informative.

  96. Staci

    You are amazing! Thank you!

  97. Janet Hoy

    I’m very pleased to discover this web site.

  98. Geoffrey

    This design is wicked!

  99. Ericka

    Hi there I am so happy I found your website.

  100. Alissa

    Thanks!

  101. Xavier Hickey

    Thanks!

  102. Ophelia

    Many thanks!

Post a comment