An Alberta provincial court judge levied fines against two companies responsible for the death of a Calgary toddler crushed by falling building materials, but the decision raises serious questions about apprenticeships and safety procedures. (June, 2011)

An Alberta provincial court judge levied fines against two companies responsible for the death of a toddler, who was crushed by falling building materials, but the decision raises serious questions about apprenticeships and safety procedures.

“I think there is no amount of money that will appease someone who has lost a three-year-old child,” said Calgary Construction Association executive vice-president Dave Smith.

“It’s a no win situation in terms of the judges decision.”

Provincial Court Judge Gerry Meagher levied the maximum $15,000 fine against Flynn Canada and Germain Residences for violating the Alberta Safety Code Act, after the death of Michelle Krsek in 2009. The companies will also pay a $2,250 surcharge.

A charge against a third company, Grenville Germain Calgary Ltd., was withdrawn.

All three companies had previously pleaded not guilty to one count each of allowing an unsafe condition.

An intense wind storm on Aug. 1, caused an individual piece of metal roofing material and a 500 lb bundle of five sheets to fall from the Le Germain building in downtown Calgary.

Court documents revealed Flynn didn’t properly secure the building materials to the roof of the Le Germain project when they left the site July 27.

“The inquiry found that of the seven one-inch screws used to secure the 500 pound plus pile of sheet metal, only four penetrated the roof surface,” said Gaven Howe, president and CEO of Howe Brand Communications.

“So, someone was using screws too short, was in a hurry, or did not have the training to think through what might go wrong, including the death of a toddler – under what scenarios could these sheets become deadly missiles?”

The metal roofing material fell 22 storeys and hit a group of people on the sidewalk across the street on 9th Avenue.

Krsek was killed instantly as a result of blunt force trauma to the head. Miroslav, her father, was knocked unconscious and critically injured, while her seven-year-old brother, Eric, was badly injured.

My opinion

Disgusting, just disgusting! $35,000 in fines for the negligent death of a little child. Disgusting!

As I have been saying all along, Alberta may understand health and safety but does not enforce the legislation it has in place.

Please read many of the blog posts on this site to see the full impact of how the province of Alberta lacks the intestinal fortitude to protect its workforce.

Remember – Alberta Health and Safety – An Oxymoron!

Remember – In Canada, “ALL Accidents are Preventable”

HRS Group Inc. has a great team that can help you with all your health and safety needs including ‘Due Diligence’, ‘Construction Safety Awareness’ and ‘Standard Operating Procedures’. Contact Deborah toll free at 1-877-907-7744 or locally at 705-749-1259.

We can also be reached at

‘Work’ and ‘Play’ safe.

Daniel L. Beal
CHSEP – Advanced Level
VP & Senior Trainer
HRS Group Inc.

397 comments on “Blog Post #521 – Max Penalty in Death of a Toddler

  1. Your style is so unique in comparison to other folks I have read stuff from.

    I appreciate you for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I’ll just bookmark this blog.

  2. As soon as I detected this internet web site I went on reddit to share some with the enjoy with them.

  3. Very good site you have here but I was curious if you knew of any discussion boards that cover health and safety as well?

  4. Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew
    of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.

  5. Greetings! Quick question that’s completely off topic.

    Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly?

  6. Excellent article! We are linking to this particularly great content on our website.

    Keep up the good writing.

  7. We are a group of volunteers and opening a new blog in our community.

    Your site provided us with helpful info to work on.

  8. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I’ve really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.

  9. Pingback: Ann Pinczak
  10. Pingback: Beatrice
  11. Pingback: Xavier
  12. Pingback: Gretchen
  13. Pingback: Washington
  14. Pingback: Dennis Stockton
  15. Pingback: Corrine
  16. Pingback: Xavier
  17. Pingback: Xander
  18. Pingback: Victoria
  19. Pingback: Penelope
  20. I just want to tell you that I am newbie to blogging and site-building and truly loved your web blog.

  21. Pingback: Nicholas Hester
  22. Pingback: Nathan
  23. Pingback: Wanda
  24. Pingback: Sean Mazur
  25. Pingback: Esther Mills
  26. I simply want to tell you that I am all new to blogging and site-building and absolutely enjoyed this web site.

  27. Pingback: Ashley
  28. Pingback: Kenneth
  29. Pingback: Michael
  30. Pingback: Bianca
  31. Pingback: Victoria
  32. Pingback: Francis
  33. Pingback: Justin
  34. Pingback: Sharon Woods
  35. Pingback: Ernest
  36. Pingback: Gregory
  37. Pingback: Ann Pinczak
  38. Pingback: Zara
  39. Pingback: Billy and Christina
  40. Pingback: Ann Pinczak
  41. Pingback: Wayne
  42. Pingback: Reggie
  43. Pingback: Ishmael
  44. Pingback: Ashley
  45. Pingback: Victoria
  46. Pingback: Carol Greenfield
  47. Pingback: Google
  48. Pingback: Bill
  49. Can I just say what a comfort to discover somebody who really knows what they are discussing on the internet.

  50. Pingback: Billy and Christina
  51. Pingback: Esther
  52. Pingback: Ashley
  53. Pingback: Webber
  54. Pingback: Wayne
  55. Pingback: Naomi
  56. Pingback: Erica
  57. Pingback: Victoria
  58. Pingback: Charles
  59. Pingback: Charles
  60. Pingback: Corrine
  61. Pingback: Warren
  62. Pingback: Maureen Chamberlain
  63. Pingback: Ashley Montague
  64. Pingback: Ashley
  65. Pingback: Ashley McFarlane
  66. Pingback: Ann Pinczak
  67. Pingback: Paul Marshall
  68. Pingback: Kelly
  69. Pingback: Norman Best
  70. Pingback: Janet Hoy
  71. Pingback: Wayne Jenkins
  72. Pingback: Vince
  73. Pingback: Nicholas
  74. Pingback: Corrine
  75. Pingback: Carol Greenfield
  76. Pingback: Carol Greenfield
  77. Pingback: Warren
  78. Pingback: Bianca
  79. Pingback: Ashley
  80. Pingback: Sharon Woods
  81. Pingback: Ashley Montague
  82. Pingback: Warren
  83. Pingback: Quinn
  84. Pingback: Quinn
  85. Pingback: Wayne
  86. Pingback: Charles
  87. Pingback: Warren
  88. Pingback: Victoria
  89. Pingback: Victoria
  90. Pingback: Xander
  91. Pingback: Wayne
  92. Pingback: Noah McGhee
  93. Pingback: Xander
  94. Pingback: Byron
  95. Pingback: Corrine
  96. Pingback: Ashley
  97. Pingback: Zachary
  98. Pingback: Zachary
  99. Pingback: Xavier
  100. Pingback: Charles
  101. Pingback: Tyler
  102. Pingback: Victoria
  103. Pingback: Bill MacKenzie
  104. Pingback: Sharon Woodhouse
  105. Pingback: Werner
  106. Pingback: Xavier
  107. Pingback: Carol Greenfield
  108. Pingback: Zachary
  109. Pingback: Nichol
  110. Pingback: Nigel
  111. Pingback: Ashley
  112. Pingback: Billy and Christina
  113. Pingback: Warren
  114. Pingback: Maureen Chamberlain
  115. Pingback: Charles Bowen
  116. Pingback: Carol Greenfield
  117. Pingback: Xerxes
  118. Pingback: Corrine
  119. Pingback: Barbara
  120. Pingback: Quincy
  121. Pingback: Charles Bowen
  122. Pingback: Marianna
  123. Pingback: Mary Pullman
  124. Pingback: Bill MacKenzie
  125. Pingback: Quinn
  126. Pingback: Maureen Chamberlain
  127. Pingback: Wendy Taylor
  128. Pingback: Maureen Chamberlain
  129. Pingback: Werner
  130. Pingback: Wendy Taylor
  131. Pingback: Quinton
  132. Pingback: Nicholas
  133. Pingback: Wayne
  134. Pingback: Kieran
  135. Pingback: Marissa
  136. Pingback: Quincy
  137. Pingback: Maureen Chamberlain
  138. Pingback: Wendy Taylor
  139. Pingback: Nicholas
  140. Pingback: Xavier
  141. Pingback: Charles Bowen
  142. Pingback: Isaac
  143. Pingback: Xavier
  144. Pingback: Xavier
  145. Pingback: Victoria
  146. Pingback: Quinn
  147. Pingback: Marianna
  148. Pingback: Shannon
  149. Pingback: Bill MacKenzie
  150. Pingback: Quincy
  151. Pingback: Xander
  152. Pingback: Dennis
  153. Pingback: Ashley
  154. Pingback: Nigel
  155. Pingback: Wayan
  156. Pingback: Michael
  157. Pingback: Michael
  158. Pingback: Francisco Martine
  159. Pingback: Warren
  160. Pingback: Warren
  161. Pingback: Warren
  162. Pingback: Quincy
  163. Pingback: Warren
  164. Pingback: Esther
  165. Pingback: Warren
  166. Pingback: Esther
  167. Pingback: Billy and Christina
  168. Pingback: Nicholas
  169. Pingback: Iris MacMullan
  170. Pingback: Warren
  171. Pingback: Nicholas
  172. Pingback: Nigel
  173. Pingback: Norman Best
  174. Pingback: Drusilla
  175. Pingback: Xavier
  176. Pingback: Morgan
  177. Pingback: Norman
  178. Pingback: Norman
  179. Pingback: Nicholas
  180. Pingback: Bill MacKenzie
  181. Pingback: Charles
  182. Pingback: Victoria
  183. Pingback: Nigel
  184. Pingback: Zachary
  185. Pingback: Nicholas
  186. Pingback: Christina
  187. Pingback: Rick Simpson
  188. Pingback: Victoria
  189. Pingback: Marissa
  190. Pingback: Morgan
  191. Pingback: Dennis
  192. Pingback: Sharon Woodhouse
  193. Pingback: Maureen Chamberlain
  194. Pingback: Billy and Christina
  195. Pingback: Wendy Taylor
  196. Pingback: Maureen Chamberlain
  197. Pingback: Corrine
  198. Pingback: Wendy Taylor
  199. Pingback: Wendy Taylor
  200. Pingback: Sharon Woodhouse
  201. Pingback: Esther
  202. Pingback: Corrine
  203. Pingback: Wesley
  204. Pingback: Warren
  205. Pingback: Larry Jackson

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.