Blog Post #271 – Protests Concerning over-crowded Jails, Staffing Shortages

HRSGroup - Providing Occupational Health and Safety Training > Blog > Blog > Health and Safety > Blog Post #271 – Protests Concerning over-crowded Jails, Staffing Shortages

Excerpt from the OH&S Canada Magazine

By: Jason Contant

Correctional officers from across Ontario held a demonstration at the North Bay Jail recently to raise concerns surrounding prison overcrowding, under-staffing issues and violence in the workplace at provincial prisons.

Attended by about 100 people, the demonstration on July 19 aimed to put pressure on senior management at the Ministry of Community Safety & Correctional Services (MCSCS) to address these concerns, which have come to a boiling point, said Dan Sidsworth, an officer at the Maplehurst Correctional Complex in Milton, Ont. and chair of the corrections division of the Ontario Public Service Employees Union (OPSEU).

The union reported that there were 485 assaults on correctional officers across the province last year and 518 in 2010, compared to 251 in 2009 – before the corrections ministry instituted a hiring freeze.

“Counterparts in the other provinces, their totals are 20 or 30 per year,” Sidsworth reported. By comparison, “ours are astronomical.”

Hiring new corrections officers has been put on hold while the corrections ministry reviews the recruitment and selection process.

“It was first done with our co-operation under the pretense that they were revamping the recruitment process, so making it more in line with other law enforcement partners,” Sidsworth said, adding that he does not anticipate any new correctional officers to be hired until next fall.

Greg Flood, an MCSCS spokesperson, said the ministry placed a moratorium on the recruitment of correctional officers in 2010 to modernize its processes. “Due to closing facilities and the transfer of staff around the province, the ministry needs time for these transitions and as such, cannot provide a date for when recruitment will resume.”

Situation leading to more agitated prisoners

The combination of overcrowding and under-staffing is leading to burnout among some officers, Sidsworth said. Although security concerns restricted him from divulging statistics on under-staffing, he said the lack of sufficient staff is forcing penitentiaries to lock down inmates more often.

“When we interact with the offenders when they’ve been locked in their cell all day, they’re more agitated, it doesn’t make our job easier at all,” Sidsworth said. “Mix the overcrowding into that and you’ve got cells that were made for one person that now have two inmates in them. And in a lot of institutions across the province, there are three inmates in the cells and some places, there are four inmates.”

OPSEU president Warren Thomas added in a statement that union members “accept that they work in potentially dangerous environments,” but the overcrowding and number of assaults are unprecedented.

Flood acknowledged that while there were cases of slight overcrowding in some jails, Ontario’s correctional facilities operated at 95 per cent capacity last year and the ministry has “strategies in place to continually assess capacity needs to ensure that beds are available where they are most needed in the province.”

Overcrowding issues in jails across the country is nothing new. On April 30, Saskatchewan ombudsman Kevin Fenwick warned in his 2011 annual report that double-bunking – housing two inmates in one cell – was already common and there was the potential for triple-bunking as well [COHSN May 7, 2012].

“Entire sections of our jails that had been closed due to their age and poor condition, and should have remained so, have been re-opened because there is nowhere else to put the inmates,” Fenwick wrote. “Overcrowding does pose serious health and safety risks for the inmates, but it also poses risks for the corrections workers tasked with supervising them.”

In February, the Manitoba Government and General Employees’ Union said the province’s seven correctional facilities were over their maximum rated capacity by more than 900 inmates, creating an abnormal, hyper-vigilant and unsafe working environment.

My opinion

The OHSA applies to all except for a certain few. This list includes firefighters, police officers and correctional officers. The law states that they can refuse excerpt where the work “is inherent in the worker’s work or is a normal condition of the worker’s employment.”

Section 43 (2) describes the vocation included in the previous list.

I wonder if over-staffing is an inherent part of the facility and, therefore, part of the expectation of their employment. I do not think so. A certain amount of expectations comes with any job but the lack of manpower to deal with the over-crowding cannot be justified. That would be like turning up the line speed and expect to have the same amount of work just because we have to. No, there would be grievances and unions would attempt to step in.

I wonder if the government has taken into account the health and safety of the correctional officers when cutting back on institutions, hence the over-crowding. Maybe we need to have a constitutional referendum at the Supreme Court of Ontario or the Supreme Court of Canada and challenge the view of the government.

The guards have a good case, I believe.

Remember — In Ontario, “ALL Accidents are Preventable”

‘Work’ and ‘Play’ safe.

Daniel L. Beal
CHSEP – Foundation Level
VP & Senior Trainer
HRS Group Inc.

Tags:

331 comments on “Blog Post #271 – Protests Concerning over-crowded Jails, Staffing Shortages”

  328. Pingback: Beverly
  329. Pingback: Kenzie

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.