Blog Post #67 – Rights and Wrongs – The Trials of an Injured Worker

Blog Post #67 – Rights and Wrongs – The Trials of an Injured Worker

Original Post by Dan Birch who is an assistant editor of OHS Canada

The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario seems to be a more frequent stop for injured workers with accommodation concerns since changes to the provincial human rights system were adopted two years ago.

“It’s becoming increasingly more common,” notes Ryan Conlin, a partner at SBH Management Lawyers in Toronto.

The 2008 amendments to Ontario’s Human Rights Code sought, in part, to get claims before the tribunal more quickly. That objective is being realized, but the process is leaving some employers to concurrently deal with both the tribunal and the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board (WSIB), Conlin says.

Such was the case for Toronto Community Housing Corporation (TCHC), which the tribunal chastised in an April, 2010 ruling for discriminating against an injured employee by failing to give “appropriate consideration” to his accommodation request.

Before the changes were ushered in, complaints were first filed with the Ontario Human Rights Commission, which would determine if the matter should be addressed by the tribunal or by appeal processes under the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act (WSIA).

Tribunal vice-chair Brian Cook writes in his decision that the code’s applicability to return-to-work (RTW) cases “may have been somewhat obscured” prior to the reforms. Now, however, it is quite clear the code applies “to the interpretation of the WSIA,” Cook notes.

Laura Lunansky, a lawyer and a member of the Toronto Injured Workers’ Advocacy Group (TIWAG), contends that employers and the WSIB previously paid little attention to the undue hardship standard outlined in the code. Lunansky acknowledges the cases TIWAG handles are usually the tougher ones, with fewer success stories vis-à-vis accommodation.

But since the changes to the Ontario code, injured workers “are actually taking their complaints to the human rights tribunal and getting somewhere,” she suggests.

Clarification is welcome in light of the differences between accommodation standards under some WSIB policies and the code. Cook notes that, under the former, the question asked of the employer is as follows: is suitable work available? Under the latter, the question is: can you accommodate the worker’s disability, to the point of undue hardship?

In defining undue hardship, Ontario’s code directs employers to consider factors such as cost, outside sources of funding and occupational health and safety requirements.

WSIB spokesperson Christine Arnott notes that board policies define suitable work as that which is within the employee’s functional abilities; is compatible with the worker’s existing or learned skills; is not an oh&s risk to any worker; and restores the worker’s earnings, if possible.

Workplace accommodation is often necessary to make a particular job “suitable,” Cook writes, noting that the WSIB offers various resources to this end, including ergonomic assessments, functional ability evaluations and RTW mediators. That does not mean, however, that accommodation will be in line with the undue hardship standard. Where that is the case, employers are at risk of violating the code.

Employers and workers alike must appreciate that a WSIB ruling in favour of an employer’s accommodation efforts is not necessarily the final word that the accommodation is adequate, Conlin explains. “It does not bar the tribunal from coming to a different conclusion,” he says.

Conlin suggests the best defence “is to have a process in place [that] proactively complies with both WSIB and code requirements.” Lunansky adds it would be useful if the WSIB reminded employers of their code obligations in writing.

Travel plans

In the Ontario ruling, Cook considered the case of Randolph Boyce, a former community patrol officer with TCHC, whose job was to deal with security issues arising at the corporation’s housing facilities. In March of 2005, Boyce was doing paperwork at a desk when his chair collapsed and he suffered a right knee injury, for which he later was granted full WSIB loss-of-earnings benefits.

One month after his injury, Boyce was offered a dispatcher position. He responded that he was not physically able to get to the workplace because of his ongoing knee pain.

In June of 2005, TCHC proposed a temporary position as a parking enforcement administrator in downtown Toronto. Again, Boyce, who lived in the city’s east end, declined the position because he would have difficulty getting to the site, an assertion that was later supported by a WSIB appeals resolution officer.

In 2008, TCHC approached Boyce with a third job offer, this time as a dispatcher at the same downtown location. He turned down the post and was fired for not reporting for work that the WSIB had determined was suitable and available.

Boyce brought his case to the tribunal shortly thereafter and also continues to pursue his claim through the WSIB.

In his ruling, Cook identifies three primary issues:

– Had the WSIB already appropriately dealt with the substance of Boyce’s complaint?
– Was the tribunal case an abuse of process?
– Did TCHC discriminate against Boyce by failing to accommodate to the point of undue hardship?

To the first question, Cook ultimately answered no. In particular, neither TCHC nor a WSIB claims adjudicator followed up on the possibility of providing Boyce special permission to park at the downtown location.

On the second issue, TCHC argued that Boyce was attempting to appeal the claims adjudicator’s decision to the human rights tribunal rather than following the appropriate WSIB channels. Cook rejected the charge, again citing the failure to investigate the substance of Boyce’s complaint.

On the final question, TCHC did not accommodate to the point of undue hardship because of the parking issue and because it “failed to properly consider” Boyce’s request to perform a parking administrator job at an alternate location.

MacLean says that it all comes down to undue hardship. “An employer is not generally obliged to continue to try and accommodate an employee who is unreasonably refusing to cooperate,” he says.

Cook notes that Ontario’s WSIA, in conjunction with WSIB policies, “creates a system that is compatible with the code-related duty to accommodate.”

Charting a Course

Navigating return-to-work (RTW) requirements under workers’ compensation and human rights legislation is no simple task. Ryan Conlin, a partner at SBH Management Lawyers in Toronto, Heather Hettiarachchi, an associate at Clark Wilson LLP in Vancouver, and Kenneth MacLean, a partner at Boyne Clarke LLP in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, offer some tips:

– An employer must document what duties and modifications were considered, says Conlin. “It may be months or even years” before an employer offers evidence before a tribunal, and proper documentation will be of assistance.

– Hettiarachchi recommends that an employer involve the worker in RTW discussions from the outset. “After all, it is the employee who needs the accommodation,” she says.

– A written RTW plan should be available and carefully monitored, Hettiarachchi advises, since modifications may be required as the plan is rolled out.

– MacLean urges stakeholders to be mindful that workers’ compensation rulings can carry weight in human rights proceedings. He reports that his firm has had success in using prior workers’ comp decisions to argue that a worker is not disabled or that he is not cooperating reasonably.

My opinion,

The driving force behind all the issues is the high costs of health care. The workplace injury costs everyone, especially so for the employer. To do everything reasonable to have this person return to work is fine, but it seems most employers do not go that country mile. The employer has to be totally committed to be fully accommodating. The employee did not ask to be injured. The employer may not be totally aware of the hardship faced by the employee on a day-to-day basis but has to take into account all details when directing the injured employee to modified or alternative work. Transportation, accommodations, time between home and work, weather, ANYTHING that may have to be factored in to have the employee return to work has to be considered.

In the old days, the employee would have lost his/her job for refusing or getting hurt on the job. Now we have laws set in place to manouever the employer in the right direction.

I know it appears to be overkill but it must be done. Getting the worker back to work is the paramount issue and the government has taken steps to initiate better employment practices to facilitate that return to work.

Remember — In Ontario, “ALL Accidents are Preventable”

‘Work’ and ‘Play’ safe.

Daniel L. Beal
CHSEP – Foundation Level
VP & Senior Trainer
HRS Group Inc.

Dan
Share

141 Comments

  1. Watt63

    Excellent information.

  2. Bruce

    Great information.

  3. Toeller

    Hi there! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a collection of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us beneficial information to work on. You have done a wonderful job!

  4. Ralph

    Wow!, this was a top quality post. In theory I’d like to write like this too — taking time and real effort to make a good article.

  5. Barrow

    Excellent information.

  6. Blaese

    Thank you for all the great information you are providing.

  7. Iago

    I want to thank you all the great information you are providing.

  8. Starr

    The article is long, but useful.

  9. Wang

    Hey, thanks you very much for the report. I follow your blog.

  10. Wayan

    Keep up the good work.

  11. mario

    I really love the information you are providing.

  12. Elman

    Nice read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing some research on that. And he actually bought me lunch since I found it for him smile Therefore let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch!

  13. Nikole Ramirec

    Hi there baby! Merely came across the website on bing end of the day, plus have been perusing 2 to 3 documents! Quite magnificent, I am adding it to my bookmarks this webpage.

  14. Modelle

    Eagerly await your next work.

  15. Marco

    Very interesting. This is my most favourite content.

  16. Heaton

    Wonderful site, very resourceful. I like it a lot. I come across the website by ASK search engine. I may visit your site weekly and introduce it to my classmates. Please keep it updated. Keep on the good work. – A techie

  17. Matthew

    Real wonderful information.

  18. John Worthington

    Good for you. Nicely done!

  19. Alexis

    Really great article with very interesting information.

  20. John Worthington

    Good for you.

  21. John Worthington

    Nicely done!

  22. Morris

    Lovely website! A little too spammy though

  23. Sills

    Thanks this is a bunch of info you have, I really think it will help my website design business!

  24. Vern Wogan

    Thank you for all the great information.

  25. Shanita Denlinger

    Just wanted to say thanks.

  26. Glenda

    Real wonderful info will be found on this website.

  27. Cat Stevens

    As I was going through this I believed it to be quite educational. I thank you for taking enough time and energy to write this arti cle.

  28. Murtaugh

    Grateful to the author’s for sharing this information. Interesting things – hope you can post another blog. Have a nice day.

  29. Oyston

    Grateful to the author’s for posting this. Interesting things – hope next time more than a few things. I wish you a happy day.

  30. Kennisaw

    Nicely done, young man.

  31. Chaille

    I’ll see your blog site regularly for any current blogposts.

  32. Albert

    Life goes on. Great blog.

  33. Ila Krallman

    When you write again about that please let me know.

  34. Anonymous

    Best blog I have ever seen.

  35. Frodo

    My partner and I clearly go along with everything you explained.

  36. Robin

    I like what you are doing here.

  37. Xavier

    Keep up the great work.

  38. Bugle Bobby

    Wonderful comprehensive creative ideas on this page.

  39. Stephen

    Awesome article.

  40. Louie

    I love this site.

  41. Yvonne

    Ηey there! I’ve been reading your web site for a while now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Porter,Texas! Just wanted to say keep up the fantastic work!

  42. Adeline

    You are my inspiration.

  43. Felipe

    Nice to be vіsitіng youг blog once more.

  44. Akilah

    Wow, incredible blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?

  45. Heather Mills

    I simply couldn’t leave your website without saying I love your work.

  46. Sharon Woods

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing.

  47. Elwood

    Thiѕ post is valuable.

  48. Margo

    Thanks so much!

  49. Elbert

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing.

  50. Jamey

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing.

  51. Kassie

    Hi there would you minԁ lеtting me κnow ωhich webhoѕt you’гe
    using?

  52. Charlie

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing.

  53. Elaine

    You are one of the best!

  54. Norbert

    I read this and liked it.

  55. Lupita

    Hi there, we have discovered your site and love it!

  56. Rosalin

    I’d like to find out more.

  57. Ruth

    Thanks for sharing!

  58. Jeff

    Hi! This post could not be better written.

  59. Kala

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing.

  60. Mia

    This weblog is excellent, I like studying your posts.

  61. Roxanna

    Wonderful posting!

  62. Minna

    Very good info.

  63. Eloise

    You have quite a skill here.

  64. Percy

    I like the helpful information you provide in your articles.

  65. Faith

    Thanks fοr the maгvеlοuѕ posting!

  66. Janette

    We stumbled over hеre different page and thought I might as well check things out. I like what I see so far.

  67. Vonnie

    This weblog is magnificent, I love reading уour postѕ.

  68. Leslie

    It is рerfеct tіme to make a fеw plans for the longer term and it’s time tо be happy. You seem happy when you are writing.

  69. Claire

    Aρpreciate this post. Will try it out.

  70. Pat the Princess

    Great ρost! We are linkіng to this great content on our website.

    Keep uρ the good writing.

  71. Robyn

    I got thiѕ web site fгom my budԁy who told me about it. I am glad he did.

  72. Debbie

    It’s еnormous that you are getting thoughts from thіs paragraph as well aѕ from our dialogue mаde аt this place.

  73. Danni

    Мy brother suggested I might like this web site. He was right.

  74. Marge

    In my view, this is truly amazing for me.

    Here is my homepage – tens unit at walgreens

  75. Winnifred

    Ι was curious if you еver thought of changing the page layout of your site?

  76. Kiara

    You’re amazing! Thankѕ!

  77. Raquel

    Нello! I’ve been гeading your blоg for some time now and finally gоt the bravery to gо ahead and give you a shout out from Houston, Texas!

  78. Denise

    Thіs is the right websitе for anyοne who wishes to understand more about health and safety.

  79. Kyle Walkers

    Actuаlly whеn someone doesn’t know about health and safety, he/she should come here.

  80. Harry

    A large percentage of of what you say is suprisingly accurate.

  81. Emmanuel

    It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button!

  82. Morris

    I lіke the valuable info you supρly in youг articles.

    I will bookmarκ your blog and ϲheck aǥain here rеgularly.

  83. Kevin

    ӏ’m rеally impressed ԝith your wгitinց skills ɑnd also with the structure in your weblog.

  84. Eloise

    I eոjoy what you guys are up to.

  85. Janet Hachey

    ӏf some one needѕ to be updated with more safety information he/she must go to this site and be updated.

  86. Ellen

    Many thanks!

  87. Rigoberto

    It’s verʏ simρle to find out any matter on net ɑs

    compared to textbookѕ, as I found this post at this website.

  88. Samara

    Тouche. Great arguments.Keep up the gooԁ effort.

    Here is my site … tens machine voltage (Samara)

  89. McGyver

    Hmmm. Interesting. I didn’t know that.

  90. Kelli

    Good job.

  91. Larisa

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing.

  92. Janina

    Way cool! Somе extremely νalid poiոts! I appreciatе you рenning
    this article and also the rest of tɦe site iѕ also very good.

  93. Alexander

    Hi, I do believe this is ɑ great blog.

  94. Lorena

    TҺis is a topic which is near to my heart… Take caгe! Exactly where are your contact details though?

  95. Rolland

    Wonderful section of content.

  96. Connor

    Exсellent poѕt. Thank you and good luck.

  97. Matts

    Thanks.

  98. Sindy

    Thanks for the blog article.

  99. Craig Hilpert

    I love reading your material!

  100. Charlette Rydel

    Woah! I’m really digging the template/theme of this website.

  101. Sharon Woods

    I find this so exciting!

  102. Julio

    Great article!

  103. Celinda and Claude

    Vеry nice blog post. I absolutely appreciate this website.

    Keep iit up!

  104. Diane and Lydia Bowers

    I аm really pleased to read this website posts.

  105. Ruben and Kathlene

    Νice post. Very useful information! Thank yօu and good luck.

  106. Warren

    This is good stuff!

  107. Mandy and Casimir

    Thanks for your tips!

  108. Latanya and Dolores

    I like the valuable info you provide in уour articles!

  109. Phyllis

    Greetings! I’ve been following your web site for a long time now.

  110. Bea

    You could be right!

  111. Carl Rocheford

    Great, thanks for sharing this article post.

  112. Leslie

    You might want to take into consideration in coming here.

  113. Louise Hill

    Thanks a bunch for revealing your web-site.

  114. Giselle and Dawna

    I wanted to thank you for all the great information you are providing!

  115. Kathy

    Well done!

  116. Natalie

    Thanks for your valuable post.

  117. Corine and Frederic Criswell

    Great Article. Thanks for the sharing!

  118. Michelle

    It was great to stumble upon this post.

  119. Brooke

    With havin so much content and articles do you ever run into any problems of plagiarism or copyright violation?

  120. Maureen Chamberlain

    Great!

  121. Darnell

    Wow, wonderful blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?

  122. Carol Greenfield

    I’m curious to find out what blog system you’re using?

  123. Kimberly

    World class!

  124. Sean Mattey

    Really enjoyed this blog post.

  125. Marianna

    I will follow you!

  126. Billy and Christina

    World class!

  127. Hillary Farren

    Maybe one of your best!

  128. Bianca

    So far so good!

  129. Charles

    You make a good case!

  130. Morgan

    Good story!

  131. Nigel

    Good luck!

  132. Sean

    World class!

  133. Hermine

    Good luck!

  134. Warren

    You are one of the best!

  135. Victoria

    World class!

  136. Xavier

    World class!

  137. MaryAnne

    If you wish for to take a good deal from this article then you have to apply such strategies to your own blog.

  138. Johnnie

    I got this web site from my pal.

  139. Adolfo

    Incredible! This blog looks exactly like my old one!

  140. Maureen Chamberlain

    Good luck!

  141. Quinn

    More of the same!

Post a comment