Excerpt from the government of Ontario’s ‘Newsroom’
Bluewater Power Distribution Corporation, the utility providing electricity distribution and related services in the Sarnia-Lambton area, has been fined $120,000 in the 2012 death of a worker who was performing repair work following the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy.
The worker was one of two who had been assigned post-storm repair work on Passingham Drive in Sarnia, where trees had downed power lines. On October 31, 2012, the two workers cleared tree limbs and began to repair the electrical lines. One worker was working from an aerial bucket while the other was working from the ground, and they began working on the downed primary neutral line.
Up until that point, the worker in the aerial bucket had been working with leather gauntlet gloves and was preparing to make the final connection by fastening the neutral end to a connector that completes the circuit path. That worker called down to the other to bring rubber gloves from the cab of their truck. While the worker was heading to the truck cab to retrieve the rubber gloves, the truck shook and the boom of the bucket dropped.
The supervisor was immediately called and both ambulance and the fire department were summoned. The worker in the bucket was taken to hospital and could not be revived. Cause of death was determined to be electrocution.
An investigation revealed that no job plan or tailboard was in place prior to the commencement of work. A job plan is typically prepared by a power line technician when the technician arrives at the job site in order to assess the work that needs to be carried out. A tailboard conference – or job site planning meeting – is used to review the job plan, identify hazards and determine how to best mitigate these hazards before work begins.
Job planning and documentation of a tailboard is a requirement under the Electrical Utility Safety (EUSR) Book, Rule 107. These rules have been established as a minimum standard for safety precautions to be followed by employers and workplaces that do not fall under the jurisdiction of Ontario Regulation 851/91 (the Industrial Establishments Regulation) or Ontario Regulation 213/91 (the Construction Projects Regulation).
In this instance, a properly-established job plan and tailboard conference would have addressed some of the key hazards and safety failings present at the site. In a statement, the worker who was on site indicated that a job plan was normally completed prior to the project; it was not completed in this instance because they were anxious to bring the power back to the community.
Although both workers had over 20 years of experience each and had been trained on the importance of wearing rubber gloves at all times upon stepping into the aerial bucket on a boom truck, the job plan and tailboard conference would have reiterated the need for using rubber gloves at all times when working on any pole or structure carrying energized conductors. The worker had been wearing leather gloves, which have a reduced electrical resistance compared to rubber gloves. Following the incident, the worker’s gloves were found to contain some dampness, which would have further weakened their resistance to electricity.
The workers should have taken the measure of treating the neutral conductor as energized (“live”) as indicated in Rule 116 of the EUSR Book.
Bluewater Power Distribution Corporation pleaded guilty to failing as an employer to ensure that workers performed a documented job plan before performing work on or in proximity to energized electrical equipment in accordance with Rule 107 of the EUSR. This contravened the measures prescribed in Ontario’s Construction Projects Regulation and the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The company was fined $120,000 by Justice of the Peace Anna Hampson in Sarnia court on May 25.
In addition to the fine, the court imposed a 25-per-cent victim fine surcharge as required by the Provincial Offences Act. The surcharge is credited to a special provincial government fund to assist victims of crime.
The law(s) violated,
Bluewater Power Distribution Corporation was found guilty of a violation of the Electrical Utility Safety Rules (EUSR) rule 107 which states,
“1. a) All work must be properly planned and communicated, taking into account all workers, the general public, approved work procedures, equipment, and the physical and environmental conditions at the workplace. The purpose of this process is to establish a safe work area by identifying the job steps, hazards and appropriate barriers. The steps to be taken in case of an emergency shall also be documented.
- b) Barriers used to protect against electrical hazards must be made of materials having an adequate electrical insulation value, and barriers used to protect against mechanical hazards must be of adequate strength for the purpose intended. Visual barriers must be used wherever practical to identify clearly the safe work area(s) for the worker(s), and/or to restrict access to unauthorized people.
- c) Visual barriers must be,
- made of approved materials;
- posted with the appropriate warnings;
- installed before the work begins; and
- respected in the same manner as other safety barriers.
- A documented job plan must be completed prior to the performance of all tasks,
- a) on or in proximity to energized electrical equipment;
- b) requiring the establishment of work protection; or
- c) involving critical hazards such as, but not limited to, falling, hoisting, confined space, hazardous substance. If a change is encountered in the job, work must stop, and the new hazard must be identified and eliminated or controlled. The revised job plan must be communicated to all workers and, where necessary, to the controlling authority before re-starting work.
- The controlling authority shall be notified of work location and duration of work when work is performed on or in proximity to equipment energized above 750 V.
- A means of communication shall be readily available at all times between the controlling authority and any work crews performing work in proximity to apparatus energized above 750 V.”
Bluewater Power Distribution Corporation was also found guilty of a violation of the Ontario ‘Construction’ regulation 213/91, section 181(1) which states,
“Except where otherwise required by this Regulation, electrical work performed on or near electrical transmission or distribution systems shall be performed in accordance with the document entitled “Electrical Utility Safety Rules” published by the Infrastructure Health and Safety Association and revised 2014.”
Bluewater Power Distribution Corporation was found guilty of a violation of the Occupational Health and Safety Act, (OHSA) section 25(1)(c) which states,
“An employer shall ensure that,
(c) the measures and procedures prescribed are carried out in the workplace.”
This particular article is self-explicit. High voltage lines and the lack of safety caused the death of a worker. If a tailgate meeting, attended by the supervisor, discussed the hazards associated with the operation, then all PPE would be provided and used in accordance with the Electrical Code.
Too bad that there was no attempt made to properly work safely here. Why couldn’t a 15minute meeting take place be part of the day’s proceedings to ensure safety? I bet it is now. Too bad for the worker and his/her family.
Ensure your workplace is a safe place.
Remember – In Ontario, “ALL Accidents are Preventable”
‘Work’ and ‘Play’ safe.
Daniel L. Beal
CHSEP – Advanced Level
VP & Senior Trainer
HRS Group Inc.