Blog Post #1169 – Elevator Fatality Results in $200,000 in Fines

Blog Post #1169 – Elevator Fatality Results in $200,000 in Fines

Excerpt from the government of Ontario’s ‘Newsroom’

The building located at 1 King Street West in Toronto is owned by Toronto Standards Condominium Corporation 1703 (TSSC 1703). Events at the property are operated by Events at One King West Ltd. (Events), which is also owned by TSCC 1703.

The building has a freight elevator, licensed by the Technical Standards and Safety Authority, that is used to carry freight, not passengers; the doors operate manually, not automatically.

On both sides of the elevator car itself, there is a door that operates similarly to a manual garage door (the car gate door) which is operated with a pull strap from the car’s ceiling to floor and travels with the elevator car.

In addition, each floor has its own doors – the landing doors – to enter the elevator car. These doors are bi-parting and part vertically to meet in the middle. These doors are also closed with pull straps located on the upper portion of the inside and outside of the landing doors.

On November 15, 2016, a worker employed by Events was assisting in the delivery and set-up of holiday decorations. The decorations were loaded on a freight elevator.

The holiday decorations were unloaded on the second floor and another worker, employed by a film production company to operate the elevator, took it to the third floor.

The elevator stopped short of the third floor, trapping the film production company’s worker, who was able to open the front car door and be pulled out of the elevator.

Upon re-entering the elevator, that worker noticed that a black stage cord that had been attached to the front car door was out of sight and reach because the front car door was in the ‘up’ position and the cord could no longer be reached to close the door.

When the elevator ascended from the second to the third floor, the black stage cord that was being used as a replacement pull strap on the car gate door got caught on the upper portion of the second floor landing door, and began to pull the upper portion of the landing door up with the elevator car.

At the same time, the worker employed by Events returned to the elevator to see if anything still needed to be unloaded, and appeared to have observed that the top panel of the landing door had opened.

The Events worker looked into the hoist-way opening created by the landing door being pulled apart.

The black stage cord then snapped and the upper portion of the landing door crashed down onto the worker, causing a fatal blunt impact injury.

The black stage cord was a replacement for the original strap usually used to close the car gate door. It had been broken on or about October 29, 2016 – about two and one-half weeks before the incident – and was initially replaced by a lanyard on that date.

On October 31, 2016, the usual elevator operator (who was employed by Events) noticed the lanyard and replaced it with a cream coloured telephone wire, and also notified the maintenance manager of Events of that temporary repair.

Sometime shortly before the incident, the telephone wire was replaced with the black stage cord. It is not clear who replaced the telephone wire with the black stage cord but it appears the telephone wire was still in place up until November 14, 2016, the day before the incident.

Investigations were conducted by the Ministry of Labour, which has responsibility for the enforcement of the Occupational Health and Safety Act, and by the Technical Standards and Safety Authority, which has responsibility for the enforcement of the Elevating Devices Regulation (Ontario Regulation 209/01).

Events failed to ensure that the freight elevator was maintained in good condition, contrary to section 25(1)(b) of the OHSA.

TSSC 1703 failed to comply with section 9(1) of Regulation 209/01 by permitting the elevator to be operated without ensuring the necessary repairs were made, rendering it unsafe.

Following a guilty plea, Events at One King West. Ltd. and Toronto Standards Condominium Corporation 1703 were fined $100,000 each (total $200,000) by Justice Malcolm McLeod in Toronto court; Crown Counsels Jennifer Malabar and Amanda Landre.

The court also imposed a 25-per-cent victim fine surcharge as required by the Provincial Offences Act. The surcharge is credited to a special provincial government fund to assist victims of crime.

My opinion

The law(s) in contravention:

Events at One King West. Ltd. and Toronto Standards Condominium Corporation 1703 were found guilty of a contravention of the Ontario regulation 209/01, “Elevating Devices” under the Technical Standards and Safety Act, section 9, subsection 1 which states,

“No person shall operate an elevating device or cause or permit it to be operated if it is in an unsafe condition.”

Events at One King West. Ltd. and Toronto Standards Condominium Corporation 1703 were found guilty of a contravention of the Ontario Occupational Health and Safety Act, (OHSA) section 25, subsection 1(b) which states,

“An employer shall ensure that,

(b)  the equipment, materials and protective devices provided by the employer are maintained in good condition.”

The TSSA and the MOL (Ministry of Labour) work very well together. The investigation had to be driven by both government agencies because all aspects of the elevator is under the control and the elevator disrepair is covered both under the TSSA but also the employer’s responsibilities listed under section 25 of the OHSA.

HRS Group Inc. has a great team that can help you with all your health and safety needs including ‘Due Diligence’ and ‘Standard Operating Procedures’. Contact Deborah toll free at 1-877-907-7744 or locally at 705-749-1259.

We can also be reached at info@hrsgroup.com

Ensure your workplace is a safe place.

Remember – In Ontario, “ALL Accidents are Preventable”

‘Work’ and ‘Play’ safe.

Daniel L. Beal

CHSEP – Advanced Level
VP & Senior Trainer
HRS Group Inc.

 

 

 

Dan
Share